Product Dissection - Gate 2
Gate 2 contains the majority of the hands on physical work involved in this project. The group followed the plans established in Gate 1 to complete the tasks of this section. There are two major tasks, including the Preliminary Project Review and the Product Dissection.
The Preliminary Project Review will look back at the past several weeks of work and assess which parts of the initial plans were successful and which need adjustments, as well as providing a solution to any unresolved problems.
The Product Dissection section will effectively lay out the dissection step by step, answering questions about challenges, tools, and methods used. This would provide an individual who has never dealt with the product a clear plan for complete dissection.
Preliminary project review
Now that the Work and Management Plans have been put to use, it is time to support, critique, and adjust the plans. Overall, the plans have worked effectively in the sense that the team has moved through the dissection process seamlessly. There were only a few minor unforeseen issues in the dissection itself, which will be covered in the Product Archaeology portion of this gate.
Group 16 has been rolling along effectively, with a few minor changes to the Management Proposal. The parts of the plan that are working are working because the group discussed how we wanted the project to unfold before we started. Most notably, the subgroups that were proposed were replaced by an as needed approach. This new approach allows flexibility, so a group member can request as many partners as needed to accomplish the goals of the day. Since we received a relatively simple product in terms of dissection difficulty, the entire team decided to attend the two designated dissection days. This gives the entire group first-hand knowledge of the process. An example of the “as needed” approach is the Parts Technician returned to the lab for an extra night to assure we had each part properly represented, assisted by the Modeling Technician.
To this point, group meetings have not been necessary, with all information and plans discussed in class and by email. As we proceed into the next several gates, weekly meetings will be incorporated to ensure all aspects of the project continue to run smoothly. There have been no challenges thus far within the group. The only problem we have encountered thus far is in wiki development. No one in our group is familiar with wiki, so the familiarization process will take some time. To avoid this problem, everyone loaded their own work to the wiki for the first gate, giving everyone a basic knowledge of how the wiki works. To overcome the challenge, the wiki developer spent this time learning the wiki program in depth. Everyone taking care of their gate 1 wiki on their own provided this extra time for the wiki developer to learn the skills. In the future, challenges will be handled much in the same manner, with all members of the team aiding in the problem to account for a difficulty within the group. If the challenge involves a lacking team member, the process outlined in the project management section will be followed.
The following table lists the parts that were taken from the Barbie KFX Kawasaki and its assembly units.
|Part Number||Part||Quantity of Part||Object Image||Part Number||Part||Quantity Required||Object Image|
|3||Seat||1||28||Pushbutton Failsafe Switch (Accelerator switch)||1|
|4||Steering column||1||29||Handel grips||2|
|5||Front clip||1||30||Steering column plate||1|
|6||Brush guard||1||31||Steering linkage cover||2|
|7||Front wheels||2||32||Wheel bushing||4|
|8||Rear wheels||2||33||Steering Linkage lower bushing||2|
|9||Foot rest||2||34||Steering column cap||1|
|10||Steering linkage||1||35||Electrical wire harness||1|
|11||#7 19T Gearbox||2||36||High speed switch cover||1|
|12||19T pinion Motor||2||37||High speed wire harness||1|
|13||Wheel cover||4||38||Power relay PC board||1|
|14||Spring cover||2||39||3/8" 16-hex nut||3|
|15||Front axle||2||40||7/16" Flat washer||7|
|16||Rear axle||1||41||7/16” Tooth lock washer||2|
|17||Foot rest support rod||2||42||8x2" Machine screw||4|
|18||Gear box cover||2||43||8x3/4" Machine screw||55|
|19||Driver||2||44||2" Fine thread machine screw||4|
|20||Hub cap||4||45||3/4" Tap screw||8|
|21||Forward/Reverse switch cover||1||46||2” Shoulder screw||1|
|22||79 Tooth gear||1||47||1/4” Machine screw||2|
|23||72 Tooth gear||1||48||12Volt Barbie Kawasaki charger||1|
|24||62 Tooth gear||1||49||12 Volt battery||1|
|25||38 Tooth gear||1||50||Mock dash board||1|
As stated before, the table below lists the assembly units contained in the Barbie KFX Kawasaki.
|Assembly units list|
|Assembly number||Name of Assembly||Components of the Assembly||Assembly Image|
|1||Gearbox motor Assembly||79 tooth gear, 72 tooth gear
62 tooth gear, 38 tooth gear
|2||Footboard Assembly||Right side foot rest
Failsafe switch accelerator switch
Foot rest support rods x2
|3||Steering system assembly||Steering linkage
Steering column cap
Steering column plate
Front axles x2
|4||Wire Harness Assembly||19T pinion motor
PC Board connector
Failsafe switch connector
12volt Battery connector
High speed wire connector
Product Dissection Plan
The table below contains a detailed step-by-step procedure to aide in the dissection of the Barbie KFX Kawasaki. The dissection process by itself takes approximately 22 minutes with at least 2 people working at steps that had several parts that could be taken off simultaneously such as step 1. The entire process of the product dissection took approximately 3 hours over 2 days in which time was taken to document the dissection process with notes and images, documenting and organizing the parts in between the steps of taking apart the vehicle.
Removal of rear axle:
The nut which holds the rear “passenger side” wheel on is secured with a significantly greater force than the opposite nut. Therefore one should not attempt to remove this nut themselves. One should instead remove only the “drivers side” wheel, nut, and driver, and then slide the whole axle out of the rear of the vehicle which will pull the wheel and driver assembly with it.
Removal of the tooth lock washer:
The tooth lock washers which hold the front axles to the steering linkage require a lot of force to remove. These clips can be removed with a flat head screwdriver. Exercise caution when utilizing the screwdriver to pry these clips off, as the excessive force on the screwdriver may cause the head to slip off the clip and cause serious injury.
- 9/16" Socket Wrench or the 9/16" wrench Assembly Tool that comes with the Barbie Kawasaki KFX
- 3/8" drive 3" long Socket extension
- 1/8" Craftsman Flat head screwdriver
- P1 and P2 Phillips head screwdrivers
1- Easy: Basic knowledge of household hardware tools(i.e screwdrivers, wrenches and so forth) required and removal of the part is a simple action i.e removing pulling out a rod from a hole.
2- Medium: Needed some prior thinking to remove the part as to not break it.
3- Hard: Multiple attempts were made to remove the part due the part not intended to be removed easily with conventional home tools.
Explanation of the scale:
Parts that were held either by screws or simply held in place by other parts being attached to it(i.e rear axle, and footrest support rods) are easy to remove with basic knowledge of household hardware tools and the axles can simply be pulled out from where they are held after the parts holding them were removed. For parts that needed prior thinking, the part had to be looked at and observed carefully as to devise an efficient way to remove it without damaging it or causing harm to the person removing it. Reasons for this included the part not originally intended to be removed but still can be removed with conventional home tools(i.e screwdriver). The only procedure that registered a 3 on the scale was the removal of the toothlock washers because they are intended not to be taken off easily due to the teeth on the washer being angled upward. They were likely put on by a pressure machine that took a fraction of second to perform the task. As a result a flat head screwdriver was used to pry it off on all sides as to not break the washer.
|Product dissection procedure|
|Step||Procedure||Tool required||Approximate time required||Difficulty scale(1-3)||Image of the process|
|1||Take off the hub caps from the wheels by using a flathead screwdriver by wedging the screw driver between the hub cap clip and the wheel cover where there are slits where the hub cap fits into in the wheel cover. The image shows where the flat head should be placed to pry out the hub caps.||1/8" Flathead screwdriver||1:00||1|
|2||Remove the wheel covers(4) by first removing the 3/8" 16-hex nut(3) from the two front wheels and from 1 of the rear wheels. Then simply remove the wheel covers from the front wheels and from the rear wheel where the hex nut was removed.||9/16" socket wrench with a 3/8" drive 3" long Socket extension.||2:00||2|
|3||Remove the wheels(2), washers and bushings from the front axle and the rear end wheel where the hex nut and wheel cover was removed. Then remove the driver and the wheel bushing from the side where the rear end wheel was removed. Remove the rear end axle by carefully pulling it out from the side where the rear end wheel has not been removed and then remove the wheel cover, driver and bushing from the axle.||none||00:30||2|
|4||Remove the brush guard by removing the 4 #8x3/4" machine screws with a P1 Philips head screwdriver. Then remove the 2 #8x3/4" machine screws from the front clip to remove it from the chassis.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||00:30||1|
|5||Remove the steering linkage cap by using a P1 Philips head to remove the #8x3/4" machine screws(2 per cap). Now remove the steering column cap by removing the #8x3/4" machine screw with a P1 Philips head screwdriver.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||1:00||1|
|6||Remove the column plate by first removing its #8x3/4 machine screw with a P1 Philips head screwdriver, then with a 1/8" Flat head screwdriver carefully force it out from the bottom of the chassis. Then remove the steering column from the chassis while carefully fishing out the high speed wire that is connected to the steering column through the hole where the steering column is located.||1/8" Flathead screwdriver
P1 Philips head screwdriver
|7||Remove the handle grips from the steering column handle bars and remove the high speed wire cover using a P1 Philips head to remove 3 #8x3/4" machine screws. Remove 2 #8x3/4" machine screws from the mock dashboard cover to remove it.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||1:00||2|
|8||First remove the seat by pressing the clip at the back end to remove it from the body. Afterwards check if the high speed wire connector is connected to the electrical wire assembly. If it is, remove the connector from the wire assembly. Remove the body by using a P1 Philips head screwdriver to remove the #8x3/4" machine screws(8) attaching the body to the chassis.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||2:00||1|
|9||Remove the tooth lock washers(2) that are attaching the steering linkage to the chassis by prying it off with a 1/8" flat head screwdriver. Do this by wedging the flat head under the washer as shown in the image by red arrows. To impede the destruction of the washer, the washer should be pried off at all sides. The steering linkage and the front axles will fallout from under so it is suggest another person hold them for support and to prevent damage.||1/8” Flathead screwdriver||1:30||3|
|10||Remove the front axles(2) the steering linkage,||none||00:30||1|
|11||First remove the he 2 #8x3/4" machine screws with a P1 Philips head screwdriver holding the forward/reverse switch cover to the body. Once the screws are out, the cover can be lifted off the body exposing the forward/reverse switch connection. Detach the forward/reverse switch from the electric wire assembly which will allow removal of the switch and cover.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||1:00||2|
|12||Use a P1 Philips head screwdriver to remove the #8x3/4" machine screws(2) from the left foot rest. Then carefully pull out the left foot rest and the foot rest support rods(2) and it is suggested that another person hold the right foot rest for some support.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||2:00||1|
|13||Use the P1 Philips head screwdriver to remove the 2 #8x3/4" machine screws from the right foot rest. Then remove the #8x3/4" machine screws from the Failsafe accelerator switch cover from the underside of the right side foot rest. Now detach the Failsafe accelerator switch from the electric wire assembly connector. Then remove the 2" shoulder screw with a P1 Philips head screwdriver to remove the pedal from the cover. The right side foot rest can now be completely removed from the chassis.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||3:00||1|
|14||Remove 3 #8x3/4" machine screws from each gearbox cover(2) from both sides of the chassis using a P1 Philips head screwdriver||P1 Philips head screwdriver||00:30||1|
|15||Detach the gearbox(2) from the 19T Pinion motor by removing the 2" fine thread machine screws(2 per gearbox) with a 1/8" flat head screwdriver.||1/8" Flathead screwdriver||00:30||1|
|16||First remove the plastic spring covers with a 1/8" Flathead screw driver by wedging the screwdriver between the spring cover clips and carefully prying them off. Take apart the chassis by using a P1 Philips head screwdriver to remove the #8x3/4" machine screws(14) holding the chassis together.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||3:00||2|
|17||Remove the PC Board from the chassis by first detaching the wire assembly PC board connectors and then using a P1 Philips head screwdriver to remove the 3/8" machine screws(2) from the PC board. The wire assembly can now be removed easily from the chassis as well.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||00:30||1|
|18||Take apart the gearboxes(2) by removing the 3 #8x3/4" tap screws(3) with a P1 Philips head screwdriver. The gears will then simply slide out of the gearbox.||P1 Philips head screwdriver||00:45||1|
Intention of Disassembly
The KFX Barbie Kawasaki is a child's toy and is not meant to be disassembled regularly. This is because the overall complexity is relatively low compared to an actual ATV. Due to this low complexity, the only maintenance that would need to be performed would be cleaning the product and the occasional inspection of the product before use to make sure it is functioning correctly. So breaking down the product is not needed at all.
There are however, many parts that are connected by screws or hex nuts; objects that can be removed by the common Philips head screwdriver and socket wrench. It can be stated that these parts are allowed to be disassembled, not necessarily meant to be disassembled in the event that a part would need to be taken apart to correct functionality such as if some weeds became wrapped up in the axles. Then the wheels would need to be removed from the axle and to do so one would need a socket wrench, a common tool in the average household.
The one part that is meant to be taken apart from the product regularly and for functionality purposes are the seat and the high speed wire connector. The seat covers the section of the chassis where the 12v battery goes and the compartment housing the high speed wire connection. This conclusion was made based on that the battery would need to be recharged and removed from the product. Removal of the seat allows access to the high speed wire connection to allow parents to enable the high speed option. The seat is connected to the product by a snap clip, a common fastener that allows for easy removal. Theoretically, this would allow easy access to the battery and the high speed connector for the user(child) as well. So potentially the child could figure out how to enable high speed for themselves or interact with the battery. Although this presents possible safety issue, the model of batteries that the Barbie KFX Kawsaki uses are generally heavy and the child would likely not have the strength to remove it. Also it is unlikely that the child would figure out how the high speed connection works at the age of 3. At older ages, the child would likely be able to handle the high speed and by then have the option already enabled by the parents.
It was concluded that the following parts were not intended to be disassembled
Steering Linkage and Tooth Lock washers
The steering linkage is secured to the chassis by two tooth lock washers. The washers have teeth angled upward so that they dig into the axle and prevent the washers from being popped off. This indicates that the steering linkage and the washers are not meant to be removed from the chassis.
Because the steering column is connected to the steering linkage and can not be removed unless the steering linkage is removed as well, this also implies the steering column is not intended to be disassembled as well.
Gearbox and Motor
Although the gearbox can be disassembled easily, it is not meant to be taken apart because of the chemical materials inside of it that pose a potential danger to the user. Taking apart the gearbox and reassembling it incorrectly will cause a cease of function, however because of the shapes of the gears, it would eventually be placed back together properly by trial and error. If maintenance needs to be done on the gearbox, it would have to be taken to a service center. The motor/gearbox assembly is also not meant to be taken apart due the complexity of assembling both the parts and ensuring that they function properly. The assembly is located in the chassis and to even reach these parts requires removing the entire rear axle along with the wheels. The motor is a very complex part in terms of function and assembly. If the motor were to be disassembled, there is a high chance that the motor would end up being destroyed in the process (without extensive technical knowledge) rendering it useless.
Product Dissection Assessment
Difficulty of dissection
In general, each component on this product was easily removed. In Table 3 above, the difficulty of each individual part's removal is assessed. The exceptions to this smooth dis-assembly procedure included the removal of the tooth lock washer and the "passenger side" rear lug nut. The tooth lock washer holds the front axles in place, and requires considerable force to remove, therefore it can be concluded that the front axle is not intended to be taken apart. Of the two rear lug nuts, only one was originally installed to be literally permanent on the rear axle. This nut was put on with such force, that no combination of wrenches, and or vice grips could remove it. Although it is still possible, then to remove the rear axle from the motor/gear box assembly, the nut was never removed, which helps to draw the conclusion that the wheels were probably not supposed to be removed by the consumer.
In the Barbie Kawasaki KFX, there are several subsystems that work together that enable the product to achieve its primary function. These subsystems include the steering column, the wheels, speed control and the motor. Figure 1. shows how the steering column connects to the chassis. The bottom of the steering column is connected to the front axle wheels by the steering linkage and is further secured against the chassis by a plastic clip(shown in figure. 2) The bottom of the steering column fits into a hole in the steering linkage which transfers the rotational energy from the handlebars, inputted by the user to the axle. This allows for the directional signal from the column to be translated to the wheels. Human energy is transferred from the operator, to the steering column in the form of rotational energy, to the wheels by means of the steering linkage. The other connected subsystems are the motor, speed control and the rear axle wheels, the last two are connected via the gearbox. The foot pedal is connected to the speed control via wires that output to the motor the desired speed. The motors are connected to the speed control and battery by more wires. There are two motors, one on each rear wheel. The gearbox is physically connected to the motor at one end(see figure 3.), and at another end the rear axle is fed through the hole in the gearbox(see figure.4). The axle goes into the gearbox and has a gear that allows for the rotation, while the gearbox itself is connected to the frame by the axle and a cover the keeps the gearbox secure against the frame. The signal is an input from the pedal, to the speed control to the motor, which in turn signals the battery to translate electricity into Kinetic energy, moving the gears and turning the axle.
- Error creating thumbnail: convert: no decode delegate for this image format `/tmp/magick-YQU39bIo' @ error/constitute.c/ReadImage/532.
convert: missing an image filename `/tmp/transform_31bcb7151c15-1.jpg' @ error/convert.c/ConvertImageCommand/3011.
Figure. 1 Red arrow showing there the steering column is place, bottom side first
- Error creating thumbnail: convert: no decode delegate for this image format `/tmp/magick-7H170K1u' @ error/constitute.c/ReadImage/532.
convert: missing an image filename `/tmp/transform_46176e5d5ad8-1.jpg' @ error/convert.c/ConvertImageCommand/3011.
Figure.2 Underside of the chassis. Red arrow shows the steering column attached to the steering linkage. Blue arrow shows the plastic plate securing the column
- Error creating thumbnail: convert: no decode delegate for this image format `/tmp/magick-4_SzIBDC' @ error/constitute.c/ReadImage/532.
convert: missing an image filename `/tmp/transform_5d53d8e43eff-1.jpg' @ error/convert.c/ConvertImageCommand/3011.
Figure. 3 Motor gearbox connection
- Error creating thumbnail: convert: no decode delegate for this image format `/tmp/magick-ck5sQBeL' @ error/constitute.c/ReadImage/532.
convert: missing an image filename `/tmp/transform_1b8856e53650-1.jpg' @ error/convert.c/ConvertImageCommand/3011.
Figure 4. Cover securing the gearbox and red arrow showing where axle is fed
The connections of each subsystem are implemented in a few different manners ranging from steering linkage connecting the steering column to the front axle, to the gearbox that connects the motor and the rear axle. Influencing these connections are some different factors. This product is aimed to be sold in America, and with the money in this country, companies are allowed to use technology on recreational vehicles, even toy such as the Barbie KFX Kawsaki. But since making money is also a factor, Fisher Price can use a plastic clip to connect two of the most important parts of the product, instead of using a metal clip. Society plays a role here as well. Since it is acceptable, and pretty much the norm, to use plastic over metal for many things in our world, consumers would not think twice as long as there was no doubt about the safety of the product. Environmental concerns led to the creation of a mostly plastic model, and choosing a standard 12 V battery that isn’t necessarily environmentally friendly, but is cheap and acceptable. Fisher price and the Power Wheels brand are trusted brands and this also implies a level of trust between the company and consumers.
The performance of this product is relatively low, so the connections don’t need to be as strong and secure as a sports car per say, but still need to account for child safety. The area of highest importance for performance is the motor and gearbox, and the gears are all plastic, encased in a plastic box. This allows for the reduction of money spent and the decreasing the weight of the prodcut.
The subsystems are arranged in manner that replicates a standard vehicle. The steering column being in the front right by the seat and the wheels are underneath the body. The motor is located in the body close to the rear axle so that the lost energy from transportation is minimized. And finally, the speed control is located by the foot pedal and in the throttle which is located in the steering column. The foot pedal is placed where your feet hang for comfort and ease of access and the throttle is in the handle for ease of use and access. The steering column and steering linkage subsystems must be adjacent to eachother in order to carry out the function of steering the product. The motor gearbox assembly and rear axle system must be adjacent to eachother to effectively perform the action of creating translational motion. However the steering system(steering column, steering linkage) can not be adjacent to the motor system(gearbox, motor, rear axle) as doing would impede the functionality of the product.
"Barbie™ Kawasaki® KFX with Monster Traction™." Fisher-price.com 27 SEPT 2010 <http://www.fisher-price.com/us/powerwheels/product.aspx?pid=47340>
"Power Wheels Parts Diagrams." mendingshed.com 13 OCT 2010 <http://powerwheels.mendingshed.com/P5066.pdf>
"Gear box Identification." Mltoyz.com 19 OCT 2010 <http://www.mltoyz.com/gb/index.html> "Washers." Mcmaster.com 20 OCT 2010 <http://www.mcmaster.com/#washers/=9dxu8z>
"Screws." Mcmaster.com 20 OCT 2010 <http://www.mcmaster.com/#screws/=9dxvso>
"Digi-Key - PB380-ND (Manufacturer - T7NS5D1-12)." Digikey.com 20 OCT 2010 <http://search.digikey.com/scripts/DkSearch/dksus.dll?WT.z_header=search_go&lang=en&site=us&keywords=T7NS5D1-12&x=22&y=22>
"Pushbutton Failsafe switch." Hellotrade.com 21 OCT 2010 <http://www.hellotrade.com/lamb-industries/pushbutton-failsafe-switch.html>